The Essentials of Trading

Information and resources to learn about trading and the markets

  • Beginner Trading Book
  • Trading Articles
  • Trading Courses
  • The Author
  • Contact

Copyright (c) 2005-19 by John Forman

You are here: Home / Reader Questions Answered / Technical analysis in manipulated markets

Technical analysis in manipulated markets

April 12, 2012 by John Leave a Comment

Tweet

This originally went up on the Currensee blog, but I think it’s something that this audience will find interesting as well.

I threw the question of what I should write about this week to a former manager of mine who was a forex dealer back in his younger years and now makes a living telling folks what’s happening in the markets. He tossed back a surprisingly good question:

How can technicals be relevant when central banks are trying to manipulate the market- BOJ with USD/JPY and SNB with EUR/CHF?

I’m sure this is something that others have pondered as well.

Here’s my view on it – speaking as someone who is very much a practicing technical analyst.

Currency intervention by a central bank or other monetary authority (in the US intervention is directed by the Treasury, though it’s executed by the NY Federal Reserve Bank) is just another news item or event that influences exchange rates. Those of us who’ve been around the markets for a while have seen a great many dramatic market reactions to all kinds of developments. Some of them have been triggered by data releases. Some have been driven by news events. Some have been caused by speakers. And some have been the result of intervention action. Heck, some of the moves have come just from the suggestion of intervention without it actually happening.

In other words, intervention is just one more thing that is reflected in the price action we see on the charts. Furthermore, it’s also something that is incorporated into the market’s expectation of the future as part of the price action we’re seeing now. The more market participants anticipate intervention, the more they will factor that into their trading and by extension the more it will influence the price action we see. It works in the same way that stock traders will price in anticipated share buybacks or weak earnings. All markets are discounting mechanisms in some fashion or another, and we can analyze the patterns that are developed in the price action through that process.

So, from my perspective, I don’t view technicals as any less useful in a market where intervention may happen. I use the same methods I would in any other case.

Now, having said that, intervention certainly presents the potential for a major volatility spike on the event (or even the hint of it). If your trading strategy or market analysis is ill-suited to that kind of thing, then while that risk is in the markets you may be best advised to either change the pair(s) you trade or to lengthen your trading time frame out to one where sharp intraday moves aren’t so much of a concern. Alternatively, you could adjust your risk so that you have less exposure for trades going against the likely direction of intervention (like when going short USD/JPY if you think the Bank of Japan is going to sell yen). The analysis doesn’t change, but how you then use it does.

Share this:

  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Reader Questions Answered Tagged With: currency intervention, foreign exchange, Forex, market analysis, Technical Analysis

FREE REPORT

The real truth about trader profitability!

ReportCover-Blue

Key Site Content

  • Trading Book Reviews
    All of the books which have been reviewed here over the years.
  • Trading Articles
    The core articles which are the backbone of the site and represent the primary educational foundation.

Recent Posts

  • Do 95% of traders fail?
  • Things took a quick turn
  • Feel like reading a PhD thesis?
  • Are you really cut out for trading?
  • Is technical analysis useful in the stock market?
  • Picking the best forex pair(s) to trade
  • Is there such thing has hybrid trading?
  • Did you really make that market call?
  • A rookie trader’s plan
  • Being a reflective trader

Recent Comments

  • João on Forex is a scam!
  • Philip on Forex is a scam!
  • Zoa on Forex is a scam!
  • teotroamer on Forex is a scam!
  • teotroamer on Forex is a scam!

Copyright 2005-2019 – The Essentials of Trading – All Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
This website, or its third-party tools, use cookies to ensure the best experience on our website. By closing this banner, scrolling this page, clicking a link or otherwise continuing to browse, you agree to the use of cookies.OkRead more